Find us on Google+ My Sensible Cent: 4 Major Challenges Kenya's MPESA Agents Go Through

Tuesday, June 16, 2015

4 Major Challenges Kenya's MPESA Agents Go Through

M-PESA is the mobile money transfer platform introduced in Kenya by Safaricom - Kenya's arguably dominant mobile network operator. It is a fact that M-PESA has revolutionized lifestyles of Kenyans in the last eight years. To-date there are about 40,000 M-PESA agents in Kenya according to statistics from the telecommunication giant. It is this extensive network of M-PESA agents that Michael Joseph attributed to the phenomenal success of the M-PESA mobile money transfer system. Although the former CEO's assertion remains arguable, the significance of the agent outlets cannot be overemphasized in analyzing the mobile money transfer system's success.

Engaging a couple of M-PESA agents in some discourse, recently, in trying to understand their contribution to the platform's success, I caught a few concerns that would qualify to be the 'Tribulations of the M-PESA agent'. Here are some :-

M-PESA in Kenya is anchored on SMS texts exchanged between individuals, agents and suppliers as 'validation notes'. The validation notes  in form of SMSs are guaranteed by M-PESA agents' deposits with Safaricom (also known as float) through a trust deed. With the maturity of M-PESA money transfer service as part and parcel of our society, even the fraudsters have joined the bandwagon to make their contribution in the diverse society. Agents have repeatedly fallen prey to these 'intelligent' citizens who send fake system withdrawal messages at outlets. Unsuspecting attendants ignorant of the authenticity of these texts dish out money only to discover the trickery when the fraudsters has  vanished.

The tricks can be as simple as sending that fake sms, to what is believed to be an inside job, where an MPESA attendant is called by a person smart enough to use codes to by pass your security codes and transfer the funds to another number. In most cases they clesr your float, leaving you helpless. How they do this is a topic for another day. Of greater concern to the agent is the fact that their contract with Safaricom pushes liability for such losses to the hapless agent.

It might be easy to think that the amounts stolen by these fraudsters using this method is little and theoretically limited to Ksh.70,000 (Maximum transaction amount per transaction) for instance. However those who are privy to operational details of  small enterprises like M-PESA agency might know that once an outlet is hit with theft of such magnitude, it could take months, years or never to recover.

2. Service Outages

Safaricom, often put out advertisement in traditional press and social media notifying M-PESA users and agents of a scheduled downtime. The scheduled outages are due to a planned upgrades of the mobile money transfer platform. A service outage for a whole day means loss of a day's worth of revenue (commissions) by agents. I am curiously shocked to learn that Safaricom have a reason to bring down a service so critical to Kenya's economy for over 32 hours. For a moment I can't prevent thinking that service availability is not an important service quality metric to Safaricom. I defer my curiosity for now until they announce the new upgrade schedule.

Scheduled outages not withstanding, it is not rare for M-PESA agents to be found helpless by customers who cannot be served because 'the network is down'. The same is experienced by customers themselves from their phone when they occasionally try to transfer money to others only to get a message that their transfer was not successful (to try again after ten minutes). Worse cases of service reliability affect M-PESA agents when a customer deposits money and there is a delay in the receiving the deposit confirmation text (on the customer's phone). The  agent is left in a precarious position of mistrust with an impatient customer who might not believe that their confirmation message will eventually come (perhaps after 20 minutes or never).

It is these planned and unplanned system outages (or degraded performance) that occasionally make the M-PESA agent a helpless businessman. Their supplier is also so powerful that they have no chance of negotiating favorable service level agreements to protect their small businesses from effects of such diminished service quality. Safaricom deserve a little more credit though. From the planned upgrade, it appears they have realized a need to improve the quality of their service. Although the planned platform improvement might alleviate some of the recurrent outages, the little bargaining power of the agents will remain a matter of concern.

3. Employee theft

Dishonesty can be argued to be prevalent among employees in Kenya.  Arguably, the desired combination of reliability and honesty among our workforce remains quite elusive. M-PESA attendants are not aliens to the purported culture of dishonesty. It should be correct to say that mobile money transfer systems include elaborate mandatory record keeping – some of which are electronically hosted by the money transfer platform. However many people forget that for as long as attendants must handle real money at some point, a temptation to steal or divert money meant for their outlet's operations exists.

Dishonest employees combined with an inept law enforcement system means that the M-PESA agent has to pray every day for their attendants not to yield to stealing temptations. The current police and justice system is such that it may be obvious who stole but nothing beyond knowing the thief is doable. It is this ever present fear of losing an outlet's cash that can permanently keep the M-PESA agent crossing their fingers. Some insurance companies I am told offer insurance cover against such losses but with 20,000 shillings 'excess' fees for any theft instance claimed. The insurance cover then rarely to makes sense to M-PESA agents since typically lost amounts are about the same as the 'excess'.

4. Fake Currency

A couple of weeks back I was listening in to one of our morning radio shows. Then there was this exasperated caller who was narrating how someone had deposited fake 20,000 shillings notes at their M-PESA outlet. The outlet's attendant had discovered the fake notes and alerted the local police before the conman had left. The police arrived at the scene, confiscated the fake notes, and left with the conman in 'custody'. To the astonishment of the agent, the police did nothing to assist agent who had already 'received' the fake deposit - hence deducted from their float. According to the caller, the conman eventually went scot free. With the current arrangement, no form of assistance was to be expected from Safaricom for mitigating such risks since the 'nonnegotiable' liability remains the agent's.

Long Conclusion

There are many other experiences that add up to miseries for M-PESA agents ranging from general risks in the external environment to business risks directly related to the nature of outlets operations. It should not surprise many that the much touted 40,000+ M-PESA agents are really not having sustainable businesses. It might also be that the extensive network of agents is the single biggest success factor of Safaricom's M-PESA platform for money transfer. In that case, with the above sentiments of M-PESA agents, it is the same factor that Safaricom has not quite controlled to their favor. Some of the M-PESA agent's troubles appear to be way out of reach in Safaricom's external environment. It is however the same environment that an entity of their size and might could work with the government to influence – for their favor. Some of the mitigation measures are as basic as additional agent capacity building.

All that said, I shall suggest that “The most significant success factor for mobile money banking operators working in Kenya will be their value proposition to Kenyan stakeholders including their customers, agents, and shareholders”. In my opinion, patriotic sentiments and feel good aspects such as corporate social responsibility will take a back seat as value drivers determine future growth paths for the competing mobile network operators.

No comments:

Post a Comment